If you have been reading my coverage of abortion-related topics with The Daily Wire, you may notice that the word “abolition” appears in nearly every article I write. Let me take a moment to explain what that means.
Since 1973, Americans have murdered over 63 million babies. Protestant denominations took nearly a decade to comprehend what was occurring—and once they finally did, a particular strategy called “incrementalism” was adopted.
If you are even vaguely familiar with the pro-life movement, you are aware of the various legislative proposals that it puts forward. Most of them work within the perceived parameters of Roe v. Wade to try and “incrementally” end abortion. Heartbeat bills ban all abortions once a baby has a beating heart; born-alive protection acts ban abortionists from killing babies if they survive abortion attempts; and pain-capable acts ban all abortions once a baby can feel pain.
For the following reasons and many more, these laws—and the movement behind them—are neither biblical, righteous, nor productive.
First, the pro-life movement does not establish equal justice.
Apply the logic of a pro-life bill to any other issue of criminal law. Would we ever laud a bill that bans sex trafficking for children between six and eighteen years of age, but greenlights it for children younger than six? Of course not—but that is the logic of the heartbeat bill. Would we ever laud a bill that lets a serial killer drown his victims, but bans him from finishing the act if they manage to crawl out of the river? Of course not—but that is the logic of the born-alive protection act. Would we ever laud a bill that lets us kill children who cannot yet walk, but bans us from killing them once they can? Of course not—but that is the logic of the pain-capable act.
God calls for His people to “seek justice, correct oppression, bring justice to the fatherless” (Isaiah 1:17). He also proclaims “woe to those who decree iniquitous decrees, and the writers who keep writing oppression, to turn aside the needy from justice” (Isaiah 10:1-2). Pro-life bills are iniquitous decrees because they do not ban murder—instead, they regulate when, how, and why it can happen. They turn our needy preborn neighbors away from justice, failing to uphold the rights of all image-bearers of God.
Second, the pro-life movement wrongly catechizes our culture.
Anyone who has ministered in front of an abortion facility can attest that mothers often raise excuses such as “my baby can’t feel pain yet,” “my baby doesn’t even have a heartbeat,” or “my baby is only ten weeks old.” Where did they learn to speak about their babies like this? From pro-life laws. The result? Their consciences are falsely soothed as they murder their own children.
Because pro-life bills—and, more broadly, the pro-life movement—treat women as “second victims” of abortion, post-abortive mothers and fathers fail to experience forgiveness through the gospel. One can only repent of sin after it is rightly defined by God’s Word. It is never loving to soften a square blow rightly delivered by Scripture—after all, love “rejoices with the truth” (1 Corinthians 13:5).
Third, the pro-life movement is built upon faulty legal premises.
When Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg passed away last year, we all remember the intense mourning from the Left. The woman was treated like a deity. But the Right manifested a similar idolatry when President Trump appointed Justice Amy Coney Barrett—there were processions and parades, the Republican establishment mobilized on her behalf, and we placed our hope of political salvation into the potential for a conservative Supreme Court.
However, for the majority of the past five decades—even during Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey—the Supreme Court has had a conservative majority. Republican-appointed Justices have perpetuated abortion—because they are equally as devoted to the ideology of judicial precedent as their Democrat-appointed counterparts.
Abortion does not need to end with the overturning of Roe v. Wade. It is not the law of the land—which is why President Biden explicitly campaigned on the promise of codifying it at the federal level. The judicial branch does not make law. It has no power to legislate from the bench. Nevertheless, all fifty states—even the ones that still have laws on the books outlawing abortion—bow to the Supreme Court’s will. At this very moment, President Biden is ignoring a recent ruling from the Supreme Court to enforce his unconstitutional eviction moratorium, and we have not heard a word from the Justices. The states are most certainly within their constitutional rights to nullify Roe v. Wade for the reason of protecting their preborn citizens.
Fourth, the pro-life movement delays actual abolition.
For the past few years, more and more Christians have begun to recognize the above truths—and innumerable others—about the pro-life movement and its legislative strategies. In response, they have been proposing bills of abolition—which outlaw abortion from conception, include no exceptions, establish equal justice for the preborn by criminalizing abortion as murder, nullify Roe v. Wade, and repeal all other statutes that greenlight abortion.
The response—even in states with Republican governors and Republican supermajorities in the legislatures—is always the same. The abolition bill is suppressed, and a pro-life bill is adopted and marketed to voters as a landmark legislative victory. Pro-life bills allow civil magistrates to avoid their biblical duty—as defined by the doctrine of interposition—to protect their constituents from the federal government when it oversteps its boundaries.
Fifth, the pro-life movement is not grounded in the biblical worldview.
Politicians, activists, and intellectuals in the pro-life movement—even the ones who are evangelical Christians—set aside their Bibles and argue against abortion from the grounds of philosophy or science. The Bibles they set aside, however, explain that men “by their unrighteousness suppress the truth” (Romans 1:18). Do philosophy and science have their place in Christian apologetics? Absolutely—but they only confirm what Scripture authoritatively declares.
The problem for the person who partakes in abortion is not a lack of evidence—it is love of sin and rebellion against their Creator. Neglecting the Word of God in the name of pragmatism—which, by the way, is the reason that most churches in America are currently filled with false converts—is rooted in unbelief in the power of God.
The pro-life movement does not hold the gospel of Jesus Christ as central—but abolitionism does.
The pro-life movement does not stand upon the solid ground of God’s Word—but abolitionism does.
The pro-life movement does not recognize that the wisdom of the world is foolishness to God—but abolitionism does.
The pro-life movement has failed—five decades and 63 million dead bodies are evidence enough. Even if its adherents have good intentions, it is time for Christians in the pro-life movement to open their Bibles and their history books to see how the Church of Jesus Christ has fought injustice through the ages.
It is time for Christians to repent of their abortion apathy and to seek justice for their preborn neighbors. God will hold us accountable on the last day for our action—or inaction.It is time for bad ideas to die and for righteous ones to take their place.
It is time to be biblical—even if it means being unpopular.
It is time to love God and our neighbors.
It is time to abolish abortion.
Editor’s Note. This was a post written on Ben Zeisloft’s personal Facebook page. Reprinted in full with permission.
